nme live review
By Justin Tyler · 2 days ago
ustin Tyler at The Lexington, London: an intimate club show with big ambitions
From the explosive opening of ‘Spaces’ to the surprise arrival of an unreleased song, Justin Tyler turns a small London room into a preview of his next musical chapter.
There's something special about seeing an artist who is beginning to think bigger in a room that feels deliberately small. At London's The Lexington, Justin Tyler brought a 19-song setlist, a growing catalogue and a noticeably renewed sense of confidence. The result was a night that moved between the reflective songwriting of his first two albums and the louder, more guitar-driven direction of his upcoming third record, Search for the Book of Life.
There was no elaborate production or oversized stage spectacle. The room was close, the crowd enthusiastic, and the atmosphere felt more like a gathering of people who had followed Tyler's journey than a conventional concert. But make no mistake: he arrived ready to play.
Opening with ‘Spaces’ was a statement of intent. The pop-rock single immediately filled the room, its driving arrangement and enormous guitar moments sounding particularly effective in a live setting. Tyler looked completely at home with the louder material, and the opening number established an energy that would carry through much of the evening.
‘Circles’ followed, bringing the audience back towards the familiar territory of Rushville. Its melodic momentum made it a natural companion to the opener, before ‘Dreaming’ introduced a more delicate side of the new material. The slower arrangement allowed the guitars to breathe, and the song's beautifully developed bridge became one of the early highlights. It was a reminder that Tyler's musical evolution isn't simply about turning up the volume.
‘Foolish Spender’ provided a welcome change of pace, its conversational character and self-deprecating humour earning a warm response. Then came the title track of Rushville, a moment that brought the evening back to the journey that helped define Tyler's career. It was followed by ‘ENRAGED’ and ‘Murder Row’, two darker selections from the Lonesome Wanderer era that gave the set a rougher edge.
The middle section became particularly interesting as Tyler moved through ‘Lyla’ and ‘Tonight We Are in Living Proof’. The latter brought some of the spontaneous spirit of From All Sides into the room, while ‘Gotham Is My Home’ offered another opportunity to revisit the imaginative world of Rushville. ‘Eras’ followed, its reflective character providing a quieter moment before the evening's biggest surprise.
Introducing the next song, Tyler admitted that he hadn't played it for an audience before.
“I'm still figuring out exactly where this one belongs,” he told the crowd. “But I thought we'd give it a go tonight.”
The song was ‘Brand New Day’, an unreleased track that offered another glimpse of the developing third album. It was one of the night's most intriguing moments. There was a sense of discovery in the room, with the audience listening closely to something that hadn't yet found its way onto streaming services or into the wider world. It also reinforced the feeling that Tyler is increasingly comfortable letting fans experience his music while it's still taking shape.
From there, the set took a darker turn with ‘Dead Men in the Grove’ and ‘Blackest Night’. The former introduced a more expansive atmosphere, while the latter brought the familiar emotional weight of Rushville back into focus. ‘Rust’ and ‘East Wind’ continued the trip through the earlier catalogue, with Tyler showing just how much ground his songwriting has covered across two albums.
By the time ‘What a Rush’ arrived, the room was ready for another burst of energy. ‘Outbound Flight’ followed, its expansive arrangement providing a fitting final chapter before Tyler left the stage.
Of course, the audience wasn't prepared to let him go just yet.
Returning for the encore, Tyler performed ‘Same Time’, closing the night on a more intimate note. After the louder guitars and the excitement surrounding ‘Brand New Day’, it was a fitting reminder of the songwriter who first introduced himself through Lonesome Wanderer.
What made this show particularly enjoyable was the way it balanced the different versions of Justin Tyler. There was the acoustic storyteller, the imaginative songwriter behind Rushville, the spontaneous performer who emerged during From All Sides, and now the increasingly confident pop-rock musician preparing to release Search for the Book of Life.
The set wasn't simply a celebration of the past. It felt like a bridge between everything Tyler has done and everything he's preparing to do next.
‘Spaces’ and ‘Dreaming’ suggest that the third album could be his most varied yet, while the appearance of ‘Brand New Day’ gave the audience a tantalising preview of what remains under wraps.
For a small London club, it was a surprisingly ambitious evening. And judging by the sound of those guitars, Justin Tyler is no longer interested in keeping things quiet.
The next chapter is coming. London just got an early look.